Mixed fortunes: Biarritz celebrate while Toulon look dejected after the final whistle in the Amlin Challenge Cup final

By Sarah Mockford, Rugby World Features Editor

In a nutshell

A RATHER drab and uninspiring final with Biarritz able to ensure their Heineken Cup qualification thanks to the boot of Dimitri Yachvili in wet conditions at the Stoop. They were fortunate, however, that Toulon couldn’t get the ball to Jonny Wilkinson in the final minutes or he could have slotted another of those drop-goals to take the game into extra-time.

Key moment

The officials’ failure to spot Yachvili’s professional foul on his opposite number Sebastien Tillous-Borde in the final ten minutes meant Toulon were not awarded a justified penalty – and perhaps a one-man advantage if the yellow card had been brandished – that would have taken them into the lead. Instead, play moved back into Toulon’s half and Biarritz slotted the penalty that gave them the victory.

Dimitri Yachvili

Boot boy: Dimitri Yachvili slots a penalty

Star man

Dimitri Yachvili is the heartbeat of this Biarritz side and his boot not only contributed all of his side’s 21 points but kept Toulon pinned back in their own half, especially in the first period. His raking kicks kept the pressure on Toulon and le petit general again inspired his team to victory.

Room for improvement

Just a hint of creativity would have sparked this game into life. Yes, the conditions weren’t the best and the game was very stop-start with errors and penalties, but it would have been nice to see either team keep the ball in hand on an occasion or two rather than resorting to relentless ping-pong.

Toulon need to look at their discipline, indiscretions giving Yachvili plenty of chances to kick at goal and resulting in two of their players being sent to the sin-bin. If they want to keep their Top 14 title hopes alive, they will need to tighten up ahead of next weekend’s play-off against Racing Metro.

In quotes – winners

Biarritz captain Imanol Harinordoquy: “This is fantastic. This season has been very hard for us but we’ve now won a title. Normally it’s Jonny Wilkinson who gives us a hard life but this time Dimitri gave Toulon a hard time.”

Jonny Wilkinson

Down and out: Jonny Wilkinson

In quotes – losers

Toulon captain Joe van Niekerk: “I’m very disappointed. The boys showed a lot of heart out there, but our discipline let us down; playing 13 against 15 meant it was an uphill battle.”

BIARRITZ: Iain Balshaw; Taku Ngwenya, Jean-Pascal Barraque, Damien Traille, Dane Haylett-Petty; Julien Peyrelongue (Marcelo Bosch 73), Dimitri Yachvili; Yvan Watremez (Sylvain Marconnet h-t), Arnaud Heguy (Benoit August 71), Eugene Van Staden (Francisco Gomez Kodela 60), Jerome Thion (Erik Lund 71), Pelu Taele, Wenceslas Lauret, Benoit Guyot (Talalelei Gray 51), Imanol Harinoroquy (capt).

Pens: Yachvili 7.

TOULON: Benjamin Lapeyre; Alex Palisson, Mathieu Bastareaud, Matt Giteau, David Smith; Jonny Wilkinson, Sebastien Tillous-Roberts; Eifion Lewis-Roberts, Sebastien Bruno (Jean-Charles Orioli 51), Carl Hayman, Christophe Samson, Kris Chesney (Dean Schofield 58), Pierrick Gunther, Steffon Armitage, Joe van Niekerk (capt).

Pens: Wilkinson 5. DG: Wilkinson.

Sin-bin: Hayman (46min), Armitage (53).